Tuesday, August 04, 2026

Willingly

Stuart K. Hayashi



I keep hearing from Sam Harris fans that neuroscience proves that humans don’t have free will. They want me to mull over their case and concede their correctness. Yet my opting — in contrast to the alternatives available — to take the initiative to contemplate their case and weigh the evidence for it is something that depends on my having the capacity to will myself freely to do all that.
 

Monday, June 29, 2026

Stop Saying There’s No Such Thing As Originality

or: The Myth of “The Myth of Originality”


Stuart K. Hayashi


Drawing by Stuart K. Hayashi from Nov. 4, 2023 to Oct. 22, 2025

Often I talk to people who think of themselves as commonsensical, and when I mention this problem, they initially doubt that it is real — they cannot fathom that smart people would say something so crazy. Nonetheless, the situation is this. It is now very fashionable for the intelligentsia to deny that originality in thought, art, and invention is important or even possible. In intellectual essays, TEDx Talks presentations, and philosophic YouTube videos they proclaim that every idea that has been hailed for “originality” is ultimately unoriginal — that there is actually no such thing as originality. In effect, the conclusion is that no one in history has every had a truly original idea.

Yes, various philosophic YouTube videos smugly proclaim, “Buddy, nothing is original, or at least not quote-unquote ‘original’ like you think it is.”

The YouTube vlogger Thoughty2 says, “The inception of a one-hundred-percent unique idea is not possible.” For that reason, he titles his YouTube video, “In Your Lifetime You'll Never Think of an Original Idea.”

Marketing expert Tom Sargent pronounces, “Once you accept ‘originality’ is basically a well-dressed lie, you can stop agonizing over ‘being unique.’ ”

Branding expert Rachel Lee adds, “There is no such thing as originality in terms of ideas, concepts, styles. There’s nothing you can create that hasn’t been created in some similar way, shape, or form.”

“Was there a point in history,” says “Erografos,” “where humans had original ideas? My personal opinion is ‘no.’”

The vlogger “Propeller Duck” begins his own video, “The concept of a completely original idea in the modern age is an often-sought-after concept despite the fact that it’s utterly impossible and, frankly, has been since the birth of modern civilization and art itself.”
 
You can see further YouTube videos denying originality-as-such over here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here and here. There are even TEDx Talks promulgating as much, as you can see here, here here, and here. People who utter lines like that always do so in a self-congratulatory manner, as if they are giving an insight of the utmost philosophic profundity. It makes sense for these people to say nothing is original when they themselves all sound alike. And the pretentiousness is sometimes accompanied with lines like, We humans want to believe we are so ingenious that we can come up with great ideas out of nowhere, but that is sheer hubris. Hence, goes the assertion, by confessing that there is no true originality we as a species are finally learning some much-needed humility. The philosophic YouTube video essayist Thomas Rebour airs those sentiments overtly in the conclusion of his own work on the topic.

In sum, this philosophic movement’s attitude is well-phrased in part of the title of a post from one prominent and well-respected intellectual blog that repeatedly advances such notions: “...the Myth of Originality.” In this context, the word myth does not refer to a valid old story that explains our origins and conveys timeless truths. Nay, by calling the concept of originality a myth both this blog post and the wider movement mean that it is altogether a falsehood.

One of the few YouTube video essayists to say anything sane on this topic has been the illustratrix “LavenderTowne.” An apologist for AI image-generators — sic; image regurgitators told her, “The fact remains that originality doesn’t exist. It’s something every type of artist knows and has known for a century.”

To that, LavenderTowne quips, “Dude, I missed that part in history class where 1920s flappers discovered that originality doesn’t exist.”

LavenderTowne tragically being the outlier, there are several different motivations for the aforementioend army of commentators to deny the existence of originality. Some of the deniers are marketing executives and Silicon Valley hotshots who bristle at frequent accusations that their work lifts heavily from that of other entrepreneurs and inventors to whom they deprive proper credit. Rather than refute such accusations, these characters reply that everything supposedly original is heavily derivative and imitative anyway, and therefore the parties from whom they allegedly filched are no better than they are. To the degree that “originality” is interpreted as one big measure of excellence, these private-sector people concede that they have not reached it, but then add that excellence in this particular form is not within reach for anyone else either. They would have it that on this measure, everyone finally learn to be resigned to such mediocrity and to such a cynical attitude.

I have heard some of these people say that they spent years in anxiety over how they could be original, and how they finally felt free to pursue their work only after they told themselves that originality is not an option for anyone else anyway and therefore they need not worry about it. It is indeed sad if someone paralyzes herself in her art on account of feeling inadequate in this department. And it is true that originality is not the only important criterion of judging quality — it might not even be the most important. But this fear does not justify this completely illogical and ultimately harmful refusal to accept the existence and long-term necessity of original thinking.

Other deniers of originality are more consciously motivated by ideology — what they insist is of greater civic merit, what with their being political-economic social collectivists. They notice that throughout the early twentieth century, the recognition of originality in particular achievements — such as those of Charles Darwin and the Wright brothers — has contributed to those achievers being celebrated as rather exceptional individuals. The more that recognition of their originality causes them to be revered as exceptional, the more that contributes to the supposed acceptance of what its detractors deride as “the Great Man Theory of History.” According to its opponents, this “Great Man Theory” posits that the course of history — the big changes in society and culture — are driven mostly by initiative in the action of particular exceptional individuals. For those who revile this idea, there is even a more-specific form of it for historical figures who specialized in STEM — what Wikipedia calls “the Heroic Theory of Invention and Scientific Development,” which is where intellectual originals such as Darwin and the Wright brothers would be placed.

These political-economic collectivists snarl that celebration of exceptional individuals is unfair. They say that just as there is an unfairly unequal distribution of wealth in society, there is likewise an unfairly unequal distribution of appreciation in terms of who is admired for progress. For them, progress is the result of the societal collective — the cumulative actions of everyone in general in society and no one in particular. In this interpretation, the lavishing of praise upon Darwin and the Wright brothers is an action that gives short shrift to everyone else, depriving everyone else of proper credit. For these political-economic collectivists, that indictment is merely an extension of their broader belief that a larger share of money going to a small number capitalists deprives everyone else in the community of the economic value that is their due. (I refute that accusation about wealth distribution here.)

For the political-economic collectivists, social justice requires that such overrated historical figures be knocked down a peg or two. One way to dress them down is to discredit any notion that these individuals were all that original. And the best and most egalitarian route of going about this is to explain that true originality is not foreseeable for anyone anyhow. In this model of thought, to revere originality is to revere an illusion — it is a manifestation of false consciousness, similar to how capitalists have supposedly brainwashed rank-and-file employees into believing they are relatively satisfied in their lower-income station.

But deny all they want — the facts are facts. Human beings do have free will. Consequently, different people make different choices in life. And some choices — especially particular dogged commitments to worthwhile endeavors — end up making a bigger impact than others. As a person’s choices are actually what most define her identity, that some choices are more impactful than others means that some people are ultimately more impactful than others. And among such impactful choices are the choice to be original in ideas and — even more decisive — the choice to commit to that original idea and pursue it to completion. (This is just as different people making different choices leads to variation in how much consumer demand each person happens to satisfy in her actions. And when one person’s choices leads to her taking actions that do substantially more than other people’s actions to satisfy consumer demand, it commensurately results in that person having a substantially larger income than those others.)

Such thinking and actionary initiative is done at the level of the individual. Thus it follows that originality in thought, as well, occurs at the level of the individual. It is not the reality that an original insight can emerge at once from everyone in general in society and nobody in particular. The original insight comes from someone psychologically independent enough to pursue an area of inquiry that she notices has not been pursued adequately by most other people. As most other people initially dismiss that insight as trivial or even oppose it as something objectionable, psychological independence is also needed for this thinker to stand by her insight and see it through. As individualism is the basis for the production of insights of great impact, it stands to reason that those who deny the importance of the individual would, in turn, deny the existence of originality in thought.

To advance the notion that the very concept of originality in human thought and endeavor is a delusion, these originality-deniers foist two interrelated promulgations.
  1. For an artwork, invention, or scientific idea to be truly original, it must be novel and unprecedented in every respect. Yet every idea that has been touted as “original” was still influenced or at least inspired by ideas that were older. For example, every artwork that has been praised for originality still relied upon many of the tropes and conventions of older forms of artwork. Similarly, every new invention that’s patented still has the attributes of older tools, equipment, and products. Hence, nothing is truly new, and there is no true originality.
  2. Historians will initially think that they have identified the first instance of someone proposing an influential idea, making a great scientific discovery, inventing an important product, or introducing a revolutionary art style. But then it turns out that this instance was chronologically preceded by some other party coming up with something that was quite similar in general idea and general premise. And further, it turns out that this predecessor, too, had been preceded by yet another party that also proposed something similar in general idea and general premise. This goes farther and farther back in time, even into antiquity B.C. And since it’s a requirement for “originality” that the allegedly-original breakthrough had no similar precedents, the fact of someone doing — or conceiving of — something even remotely similar in a chronologically-earlier period thus “de-thrones” the achievement that was held to be so original. It is therefore nothing more than a conceit to believe that experts can ever objectively ascertain which moment in history was the one of inception for some important idea, invention, or artistic medium or method. To the degree that there is change over time in customs and culture and technology, there are no “firsts” or “originals” but only a chronological continuum of sub-conceptual changes in increments cumulatively added by a societal collective. Hence, there is no originality.
Upon delivering these two arguments, a plethora of influential writers and video-bloggers confidently provide the conclusion they desire. They propound that anything and everything that you cherish as a great innovative masterpiece is actually just an imitation of something else — worse, an imitation of an imitation of an imitation of an imitation, ad infinitum. In words that Steve Jobs misattributed to Pablo Picasso, “Good artists copy; great artists steal.” These arguments are the originality-deniers’ version of “You didn’t build that.” (I refute “You didn’t build that” over here.)

The big fallacy in that sort of thinking is its false criteria for what constitutes creditworthy “originality” in an important idea, discovery, invention, or artwork. To be completely valid in praising a work for its originality does not require that, on some noumenal level, every aspect of the general idea and general premise be novel and unprecedented. 





What Originality Is and Is Not
First, we should understand that “originality” is relative. Relative, in this context, does not mean subjective or capricious. Rather, originality being relative means that it is something that is measured relationally. In effect, we observe originality by comparing this quality in one work against that of other works. Some works of fiction are more original than others; some are more derivative than others. The same applies to new inventions. Some technological innovations change our society and culture more dramatically than others do.

Inherent to this relative and relational aspect of originality is that we can zoom in and zoom out in terms of how specific and granular we want to be in evaluating the extent to which a work is novel and unprecedented — in other words, how original it is. Neither John Carpenter’s Halloween nor Sean Cunningham’s Friday the 13th were the first movie to feature a solitary and hidden villain killing off other characters one-by-one. However, Halloween chronologically preceded Friday the 13th. Moreover, Halloween strongly established, into the culture, many conventions of the nascent “slasher movie” genre, such as the killer having seemingly superhuman strength and not being killed by physical actions that would kill any ordinary mortal person. Sean Cunningham has stated publicly that the commercial success of Halloween gave him the idea to make a movie in this genre with a similar premise, Friday the 13th. Hence, although neither of these are the first horror movie or the first movie to feature a mysterious killer, in the aforementioned respects Halloween can legitimately be said to be more original than Friday the 13th. To say that Y is more original than X, of course, is not necessarily to say that Y is better overall; there are many other factors in assessing quality. Nonetheless, the degree to which an artwork is original remains an important consideration.

The reality is that to be correct and valid in valuing originality within a proposition, discovery, invention, or artwork does not require the absence of any older ideas, conventions, prior discoveries, or precedents in the presentations of the general idea and premise for it to build on. Instead, the presence of any greater-than-zero amount of novelty and unprecedentedness within a work is sufficient to prove the existence of originality and original thinking and the human capacity for all of that. And for a proposition, theory, invention, or artwork to be validly judged as highly original — and this is especially true for patent examiners — it is still not the case that the entire general idea or premise behind it be completely unprecedented. Even in possessing many attributes that have been traditional for thousands of years, a work can be validly judged as highly original if among its attributes are highly-specific-but-crucial features that are novel — either completely unprecedented or having very few known precedents. More simply, originality is found not within the general idea or general premise but instead the specific-but-crucial details that are new.


 

They Say That Instead of There Being Originality, There Is Only the “Re-Mixing” of Older Ideas Together
You might notice that if no one in history ever conceived of anything that, up to that time, had been unprecedented, there would be no changes in customs or the degree of sophistication in technology. To that consideration, the originality-deniers offer a specious reply. They say that rather than anyone ever having been original, such changes occur through what is, at best, “re-mixing.” According to this argument, everything we call “original” is actually no more than a mixture of older ideas. When such a mixture becomes particularly popular or useful and changes the culture, it is on account of this “re-mix” being both fortuitous and, ultimately, serendipitous. In his book Steal Like an Artist, cultural commentator Austin Kleon makes what he calls a vital distinction. When a re-mix is trite and unimpressive, it is “bad theft.” By contrast, Kleon avows, when a re-mix is performed cleverly and with care and provides a net gain in economic value, that is “good theft.”

A disciple of Austin Kleon’s Steal-Like-an-Artist interpretation is social-media-influencer and businesswoman Simrand Anand. On the social medium Threads, Ms. Anand does insist that developments that make truly important impacts in life actually are “not original. It’s just synthesis. That’s the magic. Synthesis is the real game now.” Fittingly enough, she is yet another TEDx Talks speaker. And she adds, “No one starts from scratch. Everyone is remixing.” That part is less synthesis or re-mix than just regular repetition of others.

It is true that when something truly original makes a grand impact on a culture, that innovation still possessed attributes that were traditional and established. Aristotle pointed this out in Section 3, Part 22, of his work Poetics. The philosopher was mostly discussing literary style, but his evaluation is applicable to almost any topic that anyone finds interesting. When you find anything to be interesting, notes Aristotle, it is located in that sweet spot between familiarity and unfamiliarity. It was from Teller, the silent half of the magician duo Penn and Teller, that I learned of Aristotle saying this. The logic of Aristotle in this is as follows. If something is completely alien and unfamiliar to me, then it will not interest me. As far as I am concerned, it has nothing to do with me. By contrast, if something is completely familiar to me, it will not interest me either. It will be boring. The reason is that I already know everything there is to know about it, and hence no further investigation is needed. Distinct from both those ends of the spectrum, when something is fascinating and arouses curiosity and desire, it is on account of how it is familiar enough to pertain to you — thereby showing immediate benefits — while its unknown aspects invite further probing and exploration on your part.

In the twentieth century, the industrial designer Raymond Loewy coined an acronym for this balance. He said that when an invention greatly satisfies marketplace demand as it hits the market, it is MAYA — Most Advanced (the unfamiliar side) Yet Acceptable (the familiar side). The familiar “Yet Acceptable” side means that it addresses issues of which you know, and that it is familiar enough to you that you can learn how to use or enjoy it. The unfamiliar “Most Advanced” side is the area of enticement — it promises either to solve problems that previously have not been solved, or to solve them more adequately than have the solutions heretofore presented.

As I am in agreement with the originality-deniers that innovations indeed possess specific qualities that are old, established, and even unoriginal, some readers might be under the misapprehension that my conclusions and the originality-deniers’ are not so incompatible after all. The reader might misapprehend that this is only a semantic difference — that what the originality-deniers and I are proposing is the same, only with my using the term originality and the originality-deniers preferring re-mix. The truth is no, there is a difference in emphasis, and the difference is so vast that the conclusions are discrete from one another. We are not in agreement.

The originality-deniers’ substitution of originality with re-mix is about placing all the emphasis on the already-existing elements — that which the allegedly-pseudo-original “artist” has “stolen” — so that the originality-deniers may, as a corollary, downplay the aspects that are novel and unprecedented. This substitution, in turn, denigrates the sophistication of mental effort taken by the originator. There are cases where the degree of unprecedentedness is so great that the term genius really applies — genius is another term that originality-deniers often dismiss and disparage as a Great-Man-Theory myth promoted by elitists.




Original Ideas Are Real and More Sophisticated Than Just “Re-Mixes” of Long-Established Ancient Ideas
There are indeed some very enjoyable music re-mixes. I am impressed by this song mash-up of Daniel Powter’s “Bad Day” with Imagine Dragons’s “Believer.” I actually prefer this mash-up over the originals. But in many instances where a new song goes to the top of the charts, it’s the case that even if the song uses chord progressions or some snippets of notes that have been used before, there is enough novelty in the product for it to warrant being acknowledged as a new song altogether. The term “originality” is good and proper. The reason is that when we recognize some innovation that has elements both familiar and novel, it is that area of novelty that produces a net gain in value in our lives and motivates and enables future innovations that provide still further net gains. That novelty in the first innovation is the origination of further routes of greater change. It is an origin and that is the root of the word originality. That is a net gain in value that is greater than a mere sum of the parts that are “mixed” and “re-mixed” together.

Insofar as a brilliantly productive application of an older idea to a new context is a “re-mix,” it is the case that in pretending a distinction between this “re-mix” and an original idea — saying “re-mixes” are real whereas original ideas are not — the originality-deniers betray an absence of understanding of ideas as such.

There are many instances in history where, upon Mr. Y applying Mr. X’s innovative method to a context different from the one in which Mr. X initially applied it, or where Mr. Y takes Mr. X’s general idea in such a way that it ends up more impactful than it did with Mr. X, many historians and writers end up associating the method or general idea more strongly with Mr. Y in their memories than with Mr. X.

Consider Henry Ford’s application of an older idea of Eli Whitney’s. In the late 1700s and early 1800s, cotton-gin inventor Eli Whitney was mass-producing guns. For the process of mass production, Eli Whitney instituted the practice of using standardized interchangeable parts. Each gun consisted of several separate parts that were assembled together, and each type of part was uniform and standardized. On account of this practice, any customer familiar with one of Eli Whitney’s guns knew that if he purchased yet another unit of this model of gun, this new unit would be of the same quality and operate in the same manner as the previous one did. Many decades later when Henry Ford was mass-producing his Model T’s on the assembly line, he instigated the same practice of working with standardized interchangeable parts. This was how Ford lowered his costs and, with them, the price per unit sold.

It is very tempting for originality-deniers to say that Ford’s application of Eli Whitney’s technique was a fortuitous “re-mix” of older ideas — less-organized car manufacturers’ plus Eli Whitney’s gun production — rather than an original idea. But note that Henry Ford took the initiative to apply this method to producing a sort of product that Whitney did not. In so doing, Ford did something momentous that even a mind as grand as Eli Whitney’s didn’t. A highly rational and productive application of an older idea to a new and heretofore untried context isn’t a mere “re-mix” of the older ideas; it is something beyond that.

We also can think of how Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace were not the first thinkers to theorize about the general idea of biological evolution — that backboned land-dwellers can descend from fishes — and yet were still innovative in presenting the specific natural-selection model that explains the mechanism of how this change occurs over time. When it comes to what Austin Kleon calls “good theft,” Darwin applied an idea of Rev. T. Robert Malthus when he and Alfred Russel Wallace formulated their specific natural-selection model. Rev. T. Robert Malthus was far from being the first economist but he was the first person upon whom a university bestowed the title of “professor of economics.” T. Robert Malthus argued that if the population of human beings in the West grows at a rate faster than does the food supply, it will create environmental pressures on humans. Then, continued Rev. Malthus, this economic pressure will influence which people live long enough to have children and raise them —and which people will die before being able to do so. Charles Darwin adapted this idea to a new context.

Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace realized that in all environments but especially in the wild, there are environmental pressures on all species, and that such environmental pressures will influence which members of a species survive and procreate and which members of that same species do not.

Here we may have a brief summary of the natural-selection model. In this model, there are natural physiological variation among members of the same species within a particular environment. Within the environment are environmental pressures — dangerous conditions that kill off some members of these species. The members of that species that possesses the physiological attributes that do not suit them to those environmental pressures will die off prior to being able to procreate. That will prevent them from transmitting those unfitting attributes to future generations. Conversely, the members of that species that do possess physiological attributes that well-fit them into the environment and which protect them against those environmental pressures will survive long enough to procreate. In turn, among their spawn will be members of the species that will likewise possess the same attributes that make them well-adapted.

In the past, such conditions in an environment were the water being shallow and in with bacteria in the water making it difficult for fishes to breathe in that oxygen through the conventional fishy method of taking oxygen-filled water through their gills. Under those environmental pressures, the best-adapted fishes were ones that could breathe air outside of water and ones in which the paired fins were be strong enough to use in crawling around in the shallows. Over millions of years, in that environment a strain of land-walking fishes had emerged. Those fishes that crawled on their paired fins were the ancestors to all backboned land-dwellers, including us humans.

The Silicon Valley originality-deniers’ argument about this being “good theft,” does not hold even if we are charitable in how we interpret it. In the charitable interpretation of the Silicon Valley originality-deniers’ argument, they would say that Darwin pursued this one aspect of Malthus’s larger theory — the part about environmental pressures on a living population — and then adapted that part (pun intended) in such a manner that Darwin had made it his own. The Silicon Valley originality-deniers would then explain that Darwin taking Malthus’s lead in this one area was the “theft” and that Darwin adding his own cleverness to improve it was the “good” side of this “good theft.”

And such phrasing on the part of Silicon Valley originality-deniers would be misleading. The consideration that it is individual physiological variations, in particular, within members of the same species in this environment that decides which ones are best-adapted to these environmental pressures is one decisive part of the natural-selection model that does not come from Rev. Malthus. That is, this consideration was not stressed by Rev. Malthus in his argument. Emphasis on this consideration is original to Darwin and Wallace.

The application of the concern about environmental pressures to all species at all times, was initiative taken by Darwin and Wallace and not by Rev. Malthus. And, indeed, the environmental pressures in deciding which members of the species successfully transmit their heritable traits across generations — and which do not — applies more consistently and accurately in the wild that Darwin and Wallace described than it does in the context of Rev. Malthus’s ultimately-failed predictions of an impending overpopulation-doomsday in the West. When an older idea is applied productively to a new context, this application is itself a new idea. And when the idea is applied to that new context for the first time, that first time is, by definition, original. To use a term from copyright law — a term beloved by YouTube video-uploaders — the new context makes the application one that is “transformative” in nature. No, Austin Kleon, that is not “good theft”; it is an origin of a new set of ideas (though not an origin of species!).
 
In the latter part of this essay I provide a series of case studies of original thinking and action in science, invention, and even art. These case studies should make clear how innovation is not to be belittled as merely a fortuitous “re-mix” of older ideas; it is an act of psychological independence and originality in thought.




Does an Inability of Historians to Agree on Identifying the “First True Model” of a Well-Established Theory or Invention Prove There Is No Originality?
Here we can also address more directly the fallacy of Argument No. 2 — that if Party Y is at first hailed as original in its intellectual achievement, only for historians to discover later that Party X chronologically preceded Party Y in exploring the same general idea, that necessarily negates and strips Party Y of all credit for its own originality. Again, originality is not at the level of the grossest and most broadly defined general idea but instead within the most significant and decisive specifics.

In scientific discovery, technological product inventions, and even artistic movements, it happens that progress is incremental.

In the history of a particular category of product, such as an automobile, coming to possess all the features that we consider standard for an automobile today — such as air-conditioning and windshield-wipers and even roofs — such features have been added over the years in many increments. For people who presume that “originality” can only occur if the entire general idea or premise behind something is wholly new and unfamiliar, the fact of improvements being incremental is a phenomenon that confuses them. The occurrence of these changes in increments misleads them into propounding that that there is no originality after all.

For example, historians can argue over which particular model or unit was “the first true automobile.” And as the different models and units were usually made by different parties, these historians can likewise argue over which of these parties was truly original in inventing the automobile. Such disagreements happen on account of different historians and other experts coming with different criteria on the specifics of what makes a “true automobile.” As many proposed candidates for “first true automobile” lack in the features that some experts consider necessary to meet the criteria for “first true automobile,” there is contention over which is the true “first.”

If what defines an automobile is simply that it is a self-powered wheeled cart — one that does not need to be pulled by an animal, such as a horse — then one possible candidate for “first automobile” might be the giant steam-powered cart that Amédée Bollée introduced to France in the year 1873. This cart was an omnibus that Bollée called L’Obéissante (the Obedient One) and it could carry up to twelve passengers at a time.

By contrast, if we define an automobile as something possessing an internal combustion engine powered directly by gasoline, then we might say a better candidate for “first” is the Benz Patent Motorwagen that Carl Benz introduced in Germany in 1885. This machine had no throttle but it did have three wheels — two in the back to move the machine forward and one in the front that determined the direction of movement as it turned with the steering wheel. In this respect, the Benz Patent Motorwagen could be thought of as a large motorized tricycle.

Yet if we define a true modern automobile as necessarily possessing four wheels instead of three, that would rule out the Benz Patent Motorwagen. We might instead consider the Mercedes 35HP that in 1901 came from the company Daimler-Motoren-Gesellschaft (DMG). This company was founded by Gottlieb Daimler. The engineers who worked most directly on the Mercedes 35HP were Gottlieb Daimler’s business partner Wilhelm Maybach and Gottlieb’s oldest son Paul Daimler. This model was commissioned by the motor-wagon distributor Emil Jellinek; his daughter was named Mercedes Jellinek, and that is how this machine model got its name. This was not the first internal-combustion-engine-possessing carriage to have four wheels, but it did have features that make it resemble our modern cars more closely than did prior such models. Such older horseless carriages were boxy and tall to match the shapes of the horsedrawn carriages more familiar to people of that time. In contrast, the Mercedes 35HP was elongated and its shape set it closer to the ground, matching the shape that we now more closely associate with compact automobiles. Also more like a modern car, the Mercedes 35HP had a long hood to protect the passenger compartment.

Originality-deniers often do know of this sequence of incremental changes in the history of automobiles. And because of their holding onto many false premises, these originality-deniers cite these incremental changes as proof of their most misbegotten conclusion. The first false premise is that for a model or unit of a device to be called “the first automobile,” it must possess all of the features now considered standard in our automobiles, such as windshield wipers and a self-starter engine. The second false premise is the one we’ve already discussed — that something is original only if the entire vague and gross general idea behind it is wholly unprecedented. And then the originality-deniers point to the fact that, for automakers to have incorporated all the features that are considered standard for an automobile today, there had to be an entire series of incremental innovations with each increment being introduced in a new model.

And as the originality-deniers are stuck on the presumption that there is no “invention of the automobile” unless all the modern standard features emerged simultaneously, they proclaim that no one party invented the automobile. And as they presume that “invention” can only occur if all the standard features of the present came to exist at the same time in the same model, they propound that it likewise follows that every technological change is a societal collective effort and no one party invented the automobile or anything else. Further, as these originality-deniers presume from the outset that “invention” and “originality” of a work can occur only if all the standard features with which we associate it today were introduced simultaneously as the first model was unveiled to the public, the originality-deniers cite this historical progression of incremental improvements — which led to the culmination of standard features we have today — as proof that there is no originality and no one truly invents anything.

Someone who espouses beliefs along these lines is Tim Wu, the law professor famous for promoting Net Neutrality. In his words, “There was, it is fair to say, no single inventor... And this reality suggests that what we call invention, while not easy, is simply what happens once a technology’s development reaches the point where the next step becomes available to many people.”

That bears repeating. For Professor Wu, invention is not someone’s proactive initiative, but “simply what happens” passively and as a foregone conclusion “once a technology’s development reaches the point” — as if this happening was not dependent upon the initiative taken by the individuals whose chose proactively to bring it there — “where the next step becomes available to many people,” those many people being rival parties that each claim to be the true inventor.

This brings to mind that intellectual blog I quoted earlier about “the Myth of Originality.” On this topic, that same blog approvingly provides a quotation from Tropic of Cancer author Henry Miller that is quite a doozy.
And your way, is it really your way? . . .

What, moreover, can you call your own? The house you live in, the food you swallow, the clothes you wear — you neither built the house nor raised the food nor made the clothes. . . .

The same goes for your ideas. You moved into them ready-made.
Hence, we can expect the originality-deniers to say that these incremental improvements are not true originality or a real invention but instead a form of what they have labeled “re-mixes” or even, at best, “good theft.” But to affix to these incremental improvements a label as banal as “re-mixes” or one as petulantly condescending as “good theft” is to downplay the extent of the ultimately dramatic net gain in value that they produce.

We must correct the falsehoods of the originality-deniers. Originality is within specific-but-crucial details, and that is what these incremental changes happen to be. The consideration that automakers arrived at the culmination of all of today’s standard features through increments, then, does not discredit the concept of originality. As with originality itself, “invention” happens in the specific-but-decisive details. Hence, originality and invention are within the incremental improvements themselves. And as these incremental improvements were introduced by separate individual parties, originality and invention and innovation still happen at the level of the individual.

For example, we can note that even if the Mercedes 35HP was not the first internal-combustion-engine-driven carriage, Wilhelm Maybach and the Daimlers still demonstrated originality and inventiveness within it. Maybach and the Daimlers were original and inventive in giving it the shape that it had and in giving it a hood that protected the passenger compartment.

We can quibble about the details in how we define the first true model of an automobile or any other invention that has historically been improved in incremental steps. Yet it holds true that there was a time in history when there were no automobiles, and now we do have automobiles. Even if we split hairs over which exact model fits our exact definition of “the first true automobile,” the fact remains that if once were no automobiles and now there are, there necessarily was a first. Acknowledgment of the fact of human creative originality does not require being able to pinpoint, at some noumenal level, some case example that perfectly fits our exact definition of the first true instance of that configuration or convention being established.




If You Apply Someone Else’s Old Idea to a New Context, Is Your Application a “Good Theft”?
Yet, even if we put aside the influence of Rev. T. Robert Malthus, the originality-deniers can still scoff that Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace do not deserve their accolades for originality. The reason for this is that Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace were preceded by many other scientists in exploring the general idea that one clade of organism can emerge from another, such as that humans and other backboned land-dwelling creatures can evolve from lobe-finned fishes. Decades earlier, Jean-Baptiste Lamarck in France brought attention to this idea. Charles Darwin’s own paternal grandfather, the innovative industrialist-physician-philosopher-poet Erasmus Darwin, contemplated this idea decades prior to the births of Charles and Alfred. Even the ancient Greek philosopher Anaximander discussed an idea like this.

Likewise, these same originality-deniers can also scoff at praise for the Wright brothers for inventing controlled and powered flight in heavier-than-air machines — airplanes. The deniers can declare that the Wright brothers were preceded by Gustave Whitehead and Leonardo Da Vinci in proposing that a heavier-than-air flying machine could be steered in flight through the warping of its wings.

Here we can acknowledge how some very significant specifics within the broader idea can make such an important difference. Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace were indeed original in identifying the natural-selection model as the specific mechanism through which evolution occurs. The specific and valid natural-selection model was something not proposed by Charles Darwin’s and Alfred Russel Wallace’s predecessors who similarly discussed the general idea of biological evolutionary change. This specific natural-selection model was not proposed by Erasmus Darwin or Anaximander. Nor was it even proposed by Jean-Baptiste Lamarck. 

Lamarck did not believe that a batch of organisms of the same species could already vary, as a default, in physiological attributes, with the ones possessing the most-adaptable natural attributes simply surviving and procreating and transmitting the same attributes over generations. That Lamarck argued that evolutionary change happened through an organism acquiring a new physiological trait over its life experiences and then transmitting that newly-acquired trait to future generations, makes the decisive specifics of Lamarck’s theory very distinct from the decisive specifics of the newer theory of Darwin and Wallace.

Thus we find that in saying that originality is found in details that are specific and decisive, I have explained what I have meant by specific; now I should elaborate further on the decisive. The decisiveness shows that it is not merely the specific detail presented by the innovative party that is new, but that the specific detail is able to go farther in achieving important effects not achieved by the other parties that preceded the innovator in presenting the general idea. In demonstrating to scientists the veracity of evolutionary theory, the Darwin-Wallace model of natural selection was able to do what Lamarckian model and other predecessors in the general idea of evolutionary theory were not able to do.

Deductive applications of the Darwin-Wallace model of natural selection produced predictions that were later empirically confirmed, whereas deductive applications of Lamarck’s model of acquired-traits evolution did not. Had Lamarck’s acquired-traits model been accurate, then it would follow that if the tails of adult mice were severed and then those adults mice were allowed to breed, then that should have a commensurate effect on the tails of their offspring. The offspring should have no tails or at least, upon their reaching adulthood, their tails should be shorter than were the tails of their parents’ prior to those tails being cut off. The scientist August Weismann put this to the test. Once the offspring had reached adulthood, their tails were always the same length that their parents’ had been prior to the parents’ tails being mutilated.

By contrast, predictions logically deduced from the Darwin-Wallace model of natural selection have a long and impeccable record of later being empirically confirmed. In 1862, Charles Darwin observed a species of orchid with a nectar tube that was thirty centimeters in length. According to the highly-original specification of the Darwin-Wallace model, the organisms that thrive and regularly reproduce are those well-adapted- to their environment — fit into it, making them the fittest. From that, Darwin logically deduced that there should be a pollinator species in the vicinity with a proboscis of commensurate length — the same thirty centimeters. In the year 1903, that species of hawkmoth was discovered. It possessed the exact same physical attribute that the Darwin-Wallace natural selection model predicted, thereby confirming the consistent principle that is the Darwin-Wallace natural-selection model. That species is even now named Xanothan praedicta — the latter word meaning “the predicted one.”

You can learn of entire litanies of instances here and here of the Darwin-Wallace natural-selection model producing scientific predictions that have been consistently verified later.

Indeed, despite the failure of Lamarck’s theoretical model to find confirmation in controlled experiments, this failure is an outgrowth of an area where Lamarck himself was original. Among the theorists of biological evolution, Lamarck was a pioneer in takin the initiative to conceive of a theoretic model that could be tested by scientific experiment in the first place. Anaximander did not get that far. Neither did even Charles Darwin’s own grandfather Erasmus Darwin.

As for the Darwin-Wallace natural-selection model, it is further original in that it originated something big that the Lamarckian acquired-traits model has not: this long record — continuing to this day — of being practically applied and vindicated empirically. Hence, the Darwin-Wallace natural-selection model is original both (1) in its specifics differing from previous models in the general idea and (2) in those specifics being decisive in originating a still-ongoing series of practical results that the previous models have not.

In our day and age, it is mainly for reasons of close-mindedness — especially religiously motivated ones — that so many Americans refuse to accept the reality of biological evolution. Such close-mindedness was already a motivation in the nineteenth century. But, back then, scientists did have legitimate reasons for reluctance in embracing it. Prior scientists who had discussed the general idea, such as philosopher Denis Diderot, the Comte de Buffon, and Erasmus Darwin had yet to present a detailed and specific model for the mechanism by which this change occurred. Such a model was needed as it could be tested in controlled experiments. As we have seen, Lamarck did provide such a model but it failed in the controlled experiments of the early twentieth century. By contrast, and as we also have seen, the Darwin-Wallace model provided the much-needed model and, from the early twentieth century and beyond, successfully passed the tests of controlled experiments.

It was because of the specific natural-selection model provided by Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace that, by the middle of the twentieth century, scientists could acknowledge, in good conscience, the veracity of the general idea of biological evolution. Darwin and Wallace were not original in discussing biological evolution, but they were original in presenting the specific and scientifically-testable natural-selection model that, through such testing, definitively proved to scientists the veracity of biological evolution. That is the decisive aspect of this exercise in originality that explains why, in the memories of scientists and even the general public, Darwin and Wallace are the historical figures most closely associated with the general idea of biological evolution.

And in the specific contents of the theory that are most decisive, enabling the ongoing practical results, Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace were truly original.

The same applies to the Wright brothers. The Wright brothers were not the first party to propose that in the powered flight of a heavier-than-air machine, steering of it could be achieved through the warping of its wings. But the Wright brothers were indeed innovative in incorporating, into this wing-warping, a more-specific method of counteracting the problem of “adverse yaw.” Adverse yaw is the tendency of a heavier-than-air flying machine’s nose to point in the direction opposite to the direction in which the flying machine is to turn. To counterbalance this frustration and maintain proper steering, the Wright brothers added a rudder to the process of the wing-warping steering. This was a decisive specific added effectively by the Wright brothers but not by Gustave Whitehead or Leonardo Da Vinci. In this they were truly original.

Note that acknowledging the originality of the specific-but-decisive detail of the natural-selection model does not diminish the stature of the insights of Lamarck, Erasmus Darwin, Anaximander, and other predecessors that have continued to hold up; these predecessors each have been validly original in their own right. Ditto goes for the Wright brothers’ predecessors — Leonardo Da Vinci and Gavin were each original in their own way.

The reality is that when an older idea is productively first applied to a new context, the newness of this particular application makes the application itself a new idea. And when the idea is applied to that new context for the first time, that first time is, by definition, original. To use a term from copyright law — a term beloved by YouTube video-uploaders — the new context makes the application one that is “transformative” in nature. No, Austin Kleon, that is not “good theft.” Applying a once-old idea productively to a new context for the first time is an exercise in originality.

This principle applies throughout history. In the end we find that the concept of “originality” is not the myth or falsehood. Below provide case studies of originality in thought throughout the past.

Below, I go over many instances where an innovator who was genuinely original in specific-but-decisive details was preceded by other thinkers in terms of exploring the general idea within which the specific-but-decisive details apply. Originality-deniers do cite the existence of these predecessors as proof that there is no originality, and insinuate that the fact of the alleged latecomer to the general idea receiving accolades for originality — such as Charles Darwin being a relative latecomer to the general idea of evolutionary theory — means that these alleged latecomers have wrongfully stolen credit for the general idea from their predecessors. In the case studies that shall follow, I shall show that these alleged latecomers do, as Charles Darwin does, deserve credit for originality. And it will follow that as these alleged latecomers do deserve their acclaim for originality, acknowledging justness of these deserts does not negate the dignity and stature of those thinkers who preceded them in exploring the general idea.

And I should add another disclaimer. We are already familiar with the assertion that on every occasion on which some authority claims to have pinpointed, in history, the first instance of an innovation, it is revealed later that someone else further back in the past had touched on that same innovation. And we have seen that what almost always happens is that while those two parties — separated by time — each made inquiries into the general idea, the latter party nevertheless engaged in original specific and decisive details that the earlier party had not.

Still, I shall be charitable to the originality-deniers here and make allowance for a risk that when I say that Mr. Y partook in the earliest-known instance of a specific innovation, some lesser-known Mr. X may have chronologically preceded Mr. Y not only in delving into the general idea of it but even in producing the same specific and decisive detail.

Should we make allowance for such a risk, though, that still would not discredit the concept of originality. For most of human history, that innovation had not existed. And now millions of human beings make use of that same innovation. Even if historians and archaeologists have not ascertained exactly when it happened or who did it — even if it turns out I am wrong in saying below that So-and-So partook in the earliest-known instance of a specific innovation — there was necessarily a first instance of that innovation and a first party to have accomplished it. That first instance was original. And so was the party that made it happen.




Antony van Leeuwenhoek Creating the Single-Lens Microscopes That Would Prove the Existence of Microscopic Organisms
In the Dutch Republic in the 1600s — the start of the Age of Enlightenment — Antony van Leeuwenhoek (pronounced LAY-ven-hweck) was able to prove the existence of microscopic organisms on account of the originality in his method of producing microscopes more powerful than those that preceded it.

It is true that Leeuwenhoek wasn’t the first person to conceive of lifeforms too small to see with the naked eye; that idea was at least as old as Lucretius of ancient Rome. Naturally, Lucretius and his contemporaries couldn’t cite any direct sensory evidence to prove it. And Leeuwenhoek was not even the first person to observe microbes under a microscope: Athanasius Kircher and Jan Swammerdam did before him, though the images from the microscope were too blurry to convince the Royal Society that these microscopic lifeforms existed. What was original about Leeuwenhoek was the extra step he took that enabled microscopes to provide direct sensory proof.

The microscopes used by Leeuwenhoek’s predecessors — such as those used by Robert Hooke in his observations of microscopic structures — possessed compound lenses that imposed distortions upon the image. By contrast, Leeuwenhoek realized that if his microscopes used a single lens, it better-focused light on the intended spot and produced a stronger, better-defined image. Unlike those of his predecessors, Leeuwenhoek grinded the single lens of his microscope to the point where it could magnify an image 270 times its original size.

That was how he was able to be the first to observe a protozoan under a microscope and name it. At first the Royal Society doubted Leeuwenhoek’s observations. But later Robert Hooke observed microbes under a microscope made in Leeuwenhoek’s method and confirmed for the Royal Society the veracity of what Leeuwenhoek described.




Gregor Mendel’s Studies in Genetics in Which He Used Mathematic Probability to Ascertain What Combo of Alleles Would Cause a Recessive Trait to Manifest in an Offspring or Not
The work in genetics by nineteenth-century Austrian monk Gregor Mendel was highly original. Here we should know the term allele, which refers to a gene that may be dominant or recessive; a recessive trait will visibly appear in a sexually-produced offspring only if it inherits the same recessive allele from each parent.

Mendel was not the first scientist to study the heritability of physical attributes of lifeforms; nor was he the first to notice that some of these traits would fail to appear in one generation of lifeforms of the same species only for these traits to appear again in the next. However, Mendel was original in how he counted the exact number of specimens with which he worked and then applied that result in using mathematical probability to predict accurately which combinations of alleles in an individual organism would make a particular inherited trait visibly appear in that same individual organism.

Yes, Mendel had some predecessors. The ancient Greek philosopher Epicurus theorized that in sexual reproduction, an offspring could inherit traits from both parents. In 1140 CE, the Spanish Jewish philosopher-poet Judah HaLevi wrote the Kuzari, a document in which he described both dominant and recessive traits. In 1819, Imre Festetics of Hungary wrote of patterns he observed in inheritance of traits over generations, such as that some traits are recessive and that some of them skip generations. In turn, Imre Festetics coined the term genetic.

John Goss, Alexander Seton, and Andrew Knight were all horticulturalists who recorded their observations of dominant alleles. Joseph Gottlieb Kölreuter did cross-breeding experiments with plants. But none of these parties counted all the offspring; nor did they apply statistics to ascertain the probability of recessive genes causing particular visible traits — called phenotypes — to manifest.

Mendel conducted systematic experiments on a massive number of individuals of the same species, counting each individual, in the task of tracking the occurrence of recessive phenotypes from recessive alleles. And, in combination with that, from his results Mendel calculated what specific ratios the specific dominant-or-recessive alleles must be arranged-in in order for particular dominant phenotypes or recessive phenotypes to manifest in an individual.

Yes: Epicurus, Judah HaLevi, Imre Festetics, John Goss, Alexander Seton, Andrew Knight, and Joseph Gottlieb Kölreuter all preceded Gregor Mendel in studying genetic heritability, and yet it was Mendel who substantially demonstrated to other scientists the veracity of the theory of genetic heritability in ways that these predecessors did not. Mendel was able to do this in his counting the number of offspring in his experiments and then using mathematic probability to decipher which combinations of alleles produced which phenotypes.

Once a scientist knew which combinations of alleles caused either a dominant or recessive trait to appear in a sexually-produced individual, and once the scientist knew what combo existed in each of its parents, the scientist could accurately predict what percentage of the parents’ offspring would display the dominant trait and what percentage would display the recessive one. And that Mendel’s model allowed for scientists at last to make such accurate predictions so confidently — whereas the theoretic models or isolated observations of Mendel’s predecessors could not — also made Mendel’s model an original one in another respect. It was that Mendel’s model originated an entire path on which Mendel’s successors would yield further reliable discoveries in genetics. Much like the mutant lobe-finned fish crawling onto land and becoming the ancestor to all backboned land-dwellers such as humans, Gregor Mendel started something new.




James Clerk Maxwell and the Invisible Spectrum of Electromagnetic Waves
We know from Aristotle that descriptions of the phenomena of magnetism go back at least as far as ancient Greece with the culture’s earliest-known philosopher and scientist, Thales. During the Song dynasty, Chinese sailors invented the compass for navigation. Benjamin Franklin explained the phenomenon of electricity. Michael Faraday, André-Marie Ampère, and Carl Gauss each wrote mathematic formulae to describe electromagnetic phenomena that they observed. But none of these people knew the exact mechanism that caused these phenomena.

James Clerk Maxwell relied on the observations of all these predecessors. The originality is in where he went farther than they did. He proposed that electricity and magnetism were ultimately the same, and, going farther still, he said that light is ultimately the same as well. Not even such scientists as Faraday, Ampère, and Gauss identified this connection between light and electromagnetism. And Maxwell said that all of these phenomena are explained by a spectrum of waves that, with the exception of light, are invisible. With the exception of light, these electromagnetic radiation waves cannot be observed directly by the senses. However, many effects of these waves can be observed directly by the senses, as exemplified by the observations of Thales and Song-dynasty Chinese sailors.

Heinrich Hertz’s experiments used sensory data to prove, empirically, the existence of the phenomenon that Maxwell deduced. Radios, mobile phones, and wireless internet connection operate according to these principles. Thales and Benjamin Franklin and Michael Faraday observed electromagnetic phenomena, but Maxwell made truly original additions to understanding that even Thales, Benjamin Franklin, and Michael Faraday did not anticipate.




Joseph Niépce and the Earliest-Known Permanent Photograph
In 1826 in France, Joseph 
Nicéphore Niépce successfully used his “heliographic” process to produce the oldest known permanent photograph. Prior to photography, ancient Chinese scholars and medieval Aristotelian Islamic philosopher-scientists such as Alhazen experimented with the camera obscura. An image would be projected through a pinhole onto the wall of a darkened room or onto a piece of paper. The darkened room is the origin of the term camera obscura, the obscura meaning “obscured” and “darkened,” and the camera meaning “chamber” or “room.” That is the origin of the word camera as we use it in the modern context, which we will get to later in this section of the essay. Naturally, in the darkened room the image lasted only as long as all of these conditions — the darkened area, the pinhole, and the setup of the projection apparatus — were in place. The next step was to find chemicals to be applied to a flat surface on which would be preserved, for the long term, all of the light reflections and refractions on a particular object, the photo’s subject.

Prior to Niépce, other experimenters from the Enlightenment and Industrial Revolution produced photographic images that faded completely away or degraded completely within hours. One of those predecessors had great scientific bona fides: Thomas Wedgwood. He was the son of the scientific potter Josiah Wedgwood, Sr. This same Josiah Wedgwood was an associate of steam-engine inventor James Watt and someone we have mentioned above, Erasmus Darwin. Indeed, Charles Darwin was the son of Erasmus Darwin’s son and Thomas Wedgwood’s older sister, which means Thomas Wedgwood was Charles Darwin’s uncle.

In the first decade of the nineteenth century, Thomas Wedgwood created photographs using silver-nitrate-coated paper. On them he produced the silhouettes of leaves — images visible on this paper in a darkened state. But within hours of being exposed to moderately bright light, such as daylight, they turned completely black. Thomas Wedgwood was flummoxed on how he could make the images longer-lasting.

Joseph Niépce used a different and original method, a process that took many hours and even days. What he did was take a pewter plate and make sure it was coated in a particular natural asphalt — specifically Bitumen of Judea. This caused the plate to harden, but not all of it: the parts exposed to bright lights were the parts that did not harden. Niepce then applied lavender oil to dissolve away the bitumen that had been exposed to bright lights — the bitumen that had not hardened. On the surface of the hardened bitumen that had remained on the plate, all onlookers would find an accurate black-and-white reproduction of a particular image, the image intended. This method Niepce called heliography — meaning “sun-graphing” or “sun-writing.” The title of this first-ever permanent photo was a description of the subject: View from the Window at Le Gras. Also as intended, the image remained long after being exposed to a lot of regular light such as daylight.

Niépce shared his findings with entrepreneur Louis Daguerre. Daguerre subsequently exercised some originality of his own. To make the images permanent, Daguerre eventually used a salt bath. In later years he used other chemical fixatives.

Joseph Niépce’s production of a permanent photograph was, to the knowledge of historians today, unprecedented. It was not a mere “re-mix” of other people’s prior actions; it was original.




Marie Curie and Radioactivity
Likewise, Marie Curie’s description of radioactivity was original. Since ancient times, human beings have handled hazardously radioactive materials. Photography pioneer Abel Niépce de Saint-Victor — cousin to the innovator we discussed above, Joseph Niépce (apparently, photography became a bit of a specialty for that family) — observed radioactivity in one respect. In 1857 Abel Niépce noticed that even when he was working in the dark, photographic emulsions could be exposed by uranium salts. But he did not go farther than that. In 1895, Henri Becquerel discovered that uranium emitted waves. But Becquerel did not extrapolate from that an entire scientific principle.

The explanation of the principles of radioactivity was original to Marie Curie. What was new was her explanation was that, unlike predecessors, she did not presume implicitly that the observed rays were a chemical reaction; she explicated that the observed rays were an atomic property inherent to particular elements such as uranium. With her husband Pierre, she isolated particular highly radioactive elements and proved that. The observation was original and so was the method of verifying it.




Chester F. Carlson and the Photocopy Machine
Paradoxically, great originality was exercise to produce a better method for making copies. This began in the interval of the years 1937 to 1938 as Chester F. Carlson developed what would eventually become the Xerox photocopier. The formal name for the technique involved is “dry electro-photography.” The dry part is important; as we shall see, Carlson would cite this principle as he came up with another name for this process.

Prior to this, a scientist in Bulgaria named Georgi Nadjakov researched some of the principles behind this method. Nadjakov found that when di-electrics were placed in an electric field and had light shined upon them, the areas that the light had touched had become permanently polarized. The polarization would cease if new light shined upon the di-electrics; yet this same polarization would persist in the dark. 3Around this same time, the physicist Pál Selényi was doing similar experiments at the Tungsram Corporation of Hungary.

The basis of these experiments was the photoelectric effect — the activity of electrons — described by by someone else I mentioned in our litany of case studies in originality, the same Heinrich Hertz who empirically proved James Clerk Maxwell’s original integrated theory of invisible electromagnetic waves and their interaction with light (the form of electromagnetic waves that is visible). Carlson read a paper by Selényi on this. And Carlson went further; Carlson was unlike Hertz and Nadjakov and Selényi in developing a specific practical device that would operate according to these same principles.

Years earlier Carlson had been an attorney working in a patent office and he had to duplicate documents by hand. Arthritis made it difficult for him. That was the basis for his curiosity about whether he could find a more convenient method to duplicate such documents.

And there were already other methods: there was carbon paper and mimeography. There was also “wet” photography such as Cyanotype. This form of photography was described as wet as it involved toxic liquids. Carlson wondered if there could be something more convenient. The absence of the toxic liquids in his remedy is why this Carlson’s process is dry electrophotography. That is also the source of the specific name that Carlson gave this process: “xerography,” the xero- for “dry” and -graphy for “writing”; it is the non-wet method for reproducible documents electro-photographically. This term is also the basis of the current name of the company most strongly associated with this technology.

Carlson would go on to license the rights to his dry electro-photocopier to Haloid Corporation. Haloid CEO Joseph Wilson then restructured the entire company around the technology and rechristened it after Carslon’s name for the technology: Xerox.

Carlson first conceived of this in 1937 and he gained his patent in October 1942 but it was not until 1960 when the first commercially successful xerographic photocopier was released, the Xerox 914. By then, Carlson’s original patent had expired. Fortunately, the business executive who first took interest in mass-producing Carlson’s invention, Joseph Wilson, was able to have Carlson gain additional patents for later improvements on the configuration. From this, Carlson and Wilson both deservedly became multimillionaires.

As we have seen, Carlson was not the first scientist to investigate the principles behind the shining of light upon di-electrics causing those di-electrics to polarize. But it was Carlson who took those principles further and saw them through to produce the first dry electro-photocopying machine. The specific decisive details behind the operation of the machine are original to Carlson himself. In this context it was our desire for more copies that necessitated an exercise in originality.




Wilhelm Röntgen and X-Rays
There was also originality in Wilhelm Röntgen’s decision to pursue some evidence discovered on accident, leading to his highly original discovery and understanding of the nature of Röntgen wasn’t the first important scientist to produce images showing X-rays. He was, however, the first among them to recognize he had found a heretofore-unidentified phenomenon. _ Three important scientists preceded Röntgen in performing experiments that yielded results that showed them directly the evidence for X-rays. The first is someone with whom we have discussed above, Heinrich Hertz. The other two were Philip Lenard and William Crookes. Although these scientists did experiments with results showing them the evidence for X-rays, these three not only did not understand the effects but dismissed them as unimportant and probed no further into them.

And the absence of curiosity on their part about these findings is surprising in light of how these other scientists were curious in other areas, the areas where they made their big discoveries. As we have seen, Heinrich Hertz conducted a controlled experiment proving the veracity of another scientist’s truly original idea: James Clerk Maxwell proposing that the electromagnetic effects observed by other scientists were caused by a spectrum of radiation airwaves that, except for light, are invisible. As for Philip Lenard, he won the Nobel Prize in physics, but then went down a much-more-tragic route. Subsequent to his work on physics, Lenard became an apologist for the Third Reich and wrote essays pronouncing that you cannot be sure if your senses provide you true important about reality as it truly is (reality at the noumenal level). Finally, Sir William Crookes discovered thallium and then gave a presentation on resource depletion, saying that unless someone could find a chemical fertilizer that could nourish an unprecedented quantity of crops, famines would ensue. Fritz Haber would on to meet Sir William’s challenge successfully, producing the ammonium nitrate fertilizer that would go on to spare two billion lives from famine.

Those important scientists also created images that showed X-rays, but dismissed the effects as fluorescent interference in their cathode ray tubes or as photographic fogging. When Wilhelm Röntgen saw the photographic evidence of X-rays, it occurred to him that he was observing a heretofore-unidentified natural phenomenon operating according to the laws of Nature. And he pursued that and proved it. The evidence itself for the phenomenon was not original, but the idea — the conceptual model — was and is.




Rosalind Franklin and Her Original Use of Insight About X-Ray Diffraction Photos to Discover the Double-Helix Structure of DNA
Yet another example of originality in thought builds upon the work of a prior thought-originators on our list — Wilhelm Röntgen with his discovery of the nature of X-rays and Joseph Niépce with his pioneering in photographs. The one to build on those originations was Rosalind Franklin in the originality through which she identified the double-helix structure of DNA. Prior to this, scientists such as Linus Pauling and Francis Crick and James Watson already had the idea that genes were located with the protein molecule DNA (deoxyribo-nucleic acid). But Pauling, Crick and Watson were not sure of the exact structure of DNA; they hypothesized that DNA had a triple-helix structure. It was Dr. Franklin’s innovation in understanding how to interpret high-quality X-ray diffraction photographs that proved DNA has a double-helix structure.

Dr. Franklin was not the first scientist to use X-ray diffraction photographs to study DNA. Florence Bell and William Astbury and Maurice Wilkins preceded her in that. But when Drs. Bell, Astbury, and Wilkins looked at the images, they did not know how to interpret the difference between DNA’s “dry” form (A-form) and its “wet” form (B-form). It was Dr. Franklin who learned how to interpret the images. She ascertained that it was an X-ray diffraction photo of DNA in its wet form that would reveal the structure. The DNA took the “wet” form after some water had been added to the “dry” form. It was by observing the new X shape in her Photo 51 of the wet form, not visible in the photos of the dry form, that Dr. Franklin inferred that DNA has a double-spiral structure.

The description of the nature of X-rays was not original to Dr. Franklin; it was original to Röntgen. Nor were permanent photographs original to Dr. Franklin; Joseph Niépce took a permanent photograph before she did. And Dr. Franklin didn’t discover the method for deciphering which combinations of alleles in an organism would result in that organism displaying a particular recessive trait; it was Gregor Mendel who did that calculation. But Röntgen didn’t use X-rays to discover the structure of DNA; Niépce didn’t consult his own permanent photographs for that either; nor did Mendel apply his knowledge of genetics for that purpose. It was Dr. Franklin who took the next vital step.

Nor was Dr. Franklin the first scientist to search for DNA’s structure in X-ray diffraction photographs. But unlike Florence Bell and William Astbury and Maurice Wilkins, it was she who applied her knowledge of the distinction between how DNA appeared in its wet form versus its dry form who could provide reliable evidence for DNA’s double-helix structure. Such insight was original to Rosalind Franklin.




Barbara McClintock’s Originality in Proving That Genes Are in Chromosomes and in Learning That Genes Can Change Location Within the DNA Sequence
In the nascent scientific discipline that Gregor Mendel’s meticulous probability work had originated, throughout the twentieth century Barbara McClintock exercised her own originality. Moreover, she was original in at least two developments: 1) co-developing the method by which she and Harriet Creighton proved that genes are located within the cell’s chromosomes and 2) discovering that within the chromosome, genes are capable of changing their location within the DNA sequence. First we shall explore how Dr. McClintock and Harriet Creighton were original in their method of proving that genes are carried in the chromosomes. As we have seen above, it was the consistent replicability of Mendel’s experiments that proved to scientists the veracity of the theory of genetic heritability and showed them particular consistent principles by which genes operate. Hence, by the opening decade of the twentieth century, biologists were already confident that within lifeforms there were “genes” that transmitted particular traits to subsequent generations. Yet these scientists still didn’t know in what part of the cell were the genes located.

However, Thomas Hunt Morgan and his students Alfred Sturtevant and Calvin Bridges suspected that the trait-determining genes were located in the chromosomes. Statistical analysis suggested that changes in chromosome correlated with changes in trait. But they had no direct physical proof. The same applied to Theodor Boveri and Walter Sutton — they, too, suspected chromosomes carried the genes, but they hadn’t proved it. Calvin Bridges noted that this seemed to be the case in that if a chromosome were absent or if there was an extra chromosome, it led to abnormalities in traits.

Thankfully, in 1931 Barbara McClintock and her student Harriet Creighton conducted a fateful experiment that would provide new confidence. Their crossbreeding of corn led to important variations. From the naked eye alone anyone could see that one type of corn produced from the crossbreeding by Drs. McClintock and Creighton happened to be both waxy and had to possess purple kernels. Then the duo made use of a testament to the originality of the aforementioned Antony van Leeuwenehoek — they used a microscope powerful enough to provide a sharp-enough image of the structures that Drs. McClintock and Creighton needed to observe.

Looking through such a microscope they found that in these waxy, purple-kerneled corns the ninth chromosome had one end that was thin and another end that was a round knob. Then the duo found another type of corn that was not waxy and had no purple kernels and looked at this type under the microscope as well. The chromosomes of this type did not have ends that were thin or ends that were round knobs. The duo bred those two types together. Among the offspring was a third type — either the ear was waxy but not purple or it was purple but not waxy.

Under the microscope, Barbara McClintock found that if the ear was waxy but not purple, its ninth chromosome had a thin end but no round knobby end. Conversely, if the ear had purple kernels but was not waxy, its ninth chromosome had a round knobby end but no thin end. A particular change in physical attribute corresponded with a particular change in the ninth chromosome.

As Lori Alexander notes in Seeds of Discovery, (New York: Clarion Books, 2025), 28–31, Barbara McClintock and Harriet Creighton deduced this syllogism:
  • The genes that determine physical attribute are located in the part of the cell whose particular change in form corresponds with the particular change in the organism’s directly observable physical attribute.
  • The chromosomes are the part of the cell whose particular change in form corresponds with the particular change in the corn’s directly observable physical attribute.
  • Therefore, the genes that determine physical attribute are located in the chromosomes.
That was original.

And that was not the end of it for Dr. McClintock. She went on to do something else highly original. It was in discovering and describing the phenomenon of “jumping genes” — that fact that a gene could excise itself from its previous location on the DNA sequence and then re-insert itself onto a different are of the DNA strand.

There were predecessors in the general idea. In 1913 while studying fruit flies, Thomas Hunt Morgan and Alfred Sturtevant found that some segments of chromosomes could switch locations with one another. In the 1930s, Hans Bauer and Emile Heitz discovered densely-packed chromosomal regions that repeated themselves — heterochromatin. These regions would be of interest to Barbara McClintock in her discovery of “jumping genes.” And from the 1930s to 1940s, Marcus Rhoades observed patterns of change in the chromosomes that didn’t always match Gregor Mendel’s simpler model.

But Barbara McClintock was the first in showing and proving that within its chromosome, a particular gene could excise itself and then insert itself into a new location in the chromosome that was not linked to the previous location. For this originality, Dr. McClintock won the Nobel Prize — very well-earned.





Sir Harold Ridley and Intra-Ocular Lenses (IOLs) for Cataract Patients
Originality in thought comes from insight. And, in this instance, it even involved literal sight. In the twentieth century, Harold Ridley had the idea that when people have cataract surgery, the damaged lenses of the eyes can be safely replaced by artificial ones, those from a transparent material known as polymethyl-methacrylate (PMMA).

As I learned from Mary Roach’s book Replaceable You: Adventures in Human Anatomy, a form of cataract surgery took place at least as early as in ancient Rome. As described by the ancient chronicler Celsus in his De Medicine, the process was severely painful and left lasting damage. The method is called couching, named from the French term se coucher, which means for something “to lie down.” (That is also the name of that sort of piece of furniture, as one can lie down on it.) The Roman practice was called couching a cataract because, rather than for the cataract to be removed completely, it was pushed downward to the bottom of the eye.

To perform this action, the surgeon first thrust a needle straight through the eye. The surgeon then made incisions in the moorings that where the lens would be held in place. Then at least the surgeon shoved the cataract below the pupil. The eye then looked clear again, which initially seemed impressive. But in the days that followed, so too did swelling, bacterial infection, and other medical complications.

During the 1700s — the Enlightenment — surgeons of the West had altered the practice. Rather than push the cataract downward, they would cut off both the cataract and the eye’s lens completely. The eye’s lenses are not completely necessary to see, but they are needed for a person to see clearly what is close to his face. Even into the early twentieth century — prior to widespread adoption of Sir Harold’s innovation, which we will soon discuss — surgeons completed this procedure without providing any replacements for the removed lenses. The best that cataract patients could do to correct the vision problem was to wear extremely large and heavy “coke-bottle” spectacles. The late comedian George Burns underwent this procedure and it is actually the reason he wore those giant glasses with which he eventually came to be associated.

The reason for which, throughout these three centuries, surgeons refused to provide any replacement lenses was that they could not find a material that was suitably safe and would not cause the aforementioned inflammation and infection. In 1747 in France, the ophthalmologist Jacques Daviel proposed replacing the natural lens surgically with a transparent human-made one. But in his time, he could not find a suitable material for the man-made lens. In 1795, a surgeon named Joannis Virgilius Casaamata also attempted to implant a glass lens onto a human eye. But it was too heavy and hurt the patient in the manner we have named.

This is where Sir Harold Ridley’s originality came into play. And he got the bright idea for it as surgeon treating injured Allied pilots during World War II.

In the war, the planes’ canopies were made of polymethyl-methacrylate (PMMA). During combat, there were incidents of the PMMA becoming embedded in the pilots’ eyes. At that point, it was safer to refrain from removing the PMMA. To Sir Harold’s surprise, the PMMA didn’t cause inflammation. During the war many other surgeons for the Allies made this same observation but did nothing more with it for the rest of their lives. By contrast, Sir Harold had the original idea of pursuing a course on which he could apply this special knowledge. It occurred to Sir Harold that perhaps a lightweight transparent material — possibly PMMA or something similar to it — could be safely implanted onto the eye. And it dawned on Sir Harold that cataract patients, in particular, would benefit from this.

Thankfully it was in Sir Harold Ridley’s lifetime that industrial chemists and chemical engineers had made available the lightweight transparent materials that Sir Harold needed. Sir Harold’s choice to use PMMA — in particular Rayner Optical Company’s Transpex I and Pespex CQ models — for his intraocular lenses (IOLs) was a truly original idea. To protect Sir Harold’s work commercially, with Sir Harold’s permission Dr. Peter Choyce patented early models of the IOLs. Such doctors as Peter LaHaye and Michael Belkin became multimillionaires from patenting further innovations on this device.

Since 1989, increasingly intraocular lenses have been made of silicone or acrylic materials. There are still some circumstances where PMMA is preferable, and PMMA is still the main material used for IOLs in the Third World.

It was originality in thought that made this practical restoration of sight a reality. And I hope that you, the reader, can see this as well.




Karl Landsteiner and Blood Type
And then there is blood type. Throughout the Renaissance, doctors attempted blood transfusions. They were repeatedly met with failure as the patients died. This was a cause of consternation, as, theoretically, the blood transfusions should have worked. In 1900, Karl Landsteiner explained that there are different particular blood types, and that, if you have one blood type, whether you survive the transfusion depends on the blood type of the blood you receive. The successful transfusions that followed are a testament to the efficacy of Landsteiner’s idea, an idea that was truly original.




Antoine Lavoisier Proving the Oxygen Theory of Combustion
Antoine Lavoisier’s explanation that the addition of oxygen is required for combustion to occur is an explanation that followed a long series of missteps in science. In ancient Greece, Empedocles said that fire was one of four elements that could not be reduced to simpler form. Aristotle said the same, except Aristotle added a fifth element he called “ether.” This was the dominant model among alchemists until Robert Boyle formalized chemistry as a hard science involving a strict and consistent methodology. In the 1600s, the German alchemist Johann Joachim Becher started what would, for a century, become the leading scientific authority’s leading theory in how objects catch fire: phlogiston theory. The phlogiston refers to the Greek root phlox, which means “flame.” Becher’s phlogiston theory was that all objects have an innate “fieriness” in them that is stored but dormant. When the object catches fire, said Becher, it mean the innate fieriness was no longer dormant, being activated and releasing material. According to Becher, the moment of combustion was the exact moment that the object lost mass.

In the 1700s, Joseph Priestley and Carl Scheele each independently discovered the element oxygen by isolating it from all other elements. In the 1600s, the English alchemist John Mayow discovered that for an object to start to combust, something from the air must be added to it. But he did not know which chemical or chemicals it was; as a placeholder he used the term nitro-aerial spirit. Then in the 1700s, Antoine Lavoisier put it all together: at the moment that an object began to combust, another greater-than-zero quantity of mass had been added, contradicting phlogiston theory. And that additional mass was a specific element that he was able to identify by isolating: oxygen. It was even Lavoisier — not Joseph Priestley or Carl Scheele — who gave this element the name of oxygen.

Other scientists had preceded Lavoisier in introducing parts of the theory. Priestley and Scheele each discovered the element oxygen in particular through isolating it, but did not notice that the introduction of oxygen was needed for combustion. Conversely, John Mayow did know that a sort of particle from the air needed to be added to an object for it to combust, but Mayow did not know which chemical it was, and he could not prove which chemical in particular it was as he did not isolate the oxygen. When Lavoisier put it all together, the result was something greater than the sum of its parts: for there to be an explanation that would advance scientific understanding, all of this theory’s elements — pun intended — had to be in place. It is a grotesque insult to everyone’s intelligence to give this mental integration of Lavoisier’s a label as petty as “good theft”; in intellectual achievement and consequence it is beyond a merely fortuitous “re-mix” of older established ideas. In putting the important pieces together in the exact places where they properly fit, Antoine Lavoisier was truly original.




Many Instances of Original Thinking in the History of Early Cartoon Animation
Above I have provided a litany of scientists whose discoveries were original ideas, and many of them were also original in their methodology of finding this information and building a strong case that they had discovered was indeed a consistently applicable natural law. Still, someone might say that the discoverer was ultimately passive in that the phenomenon already existed in Nature — that the discoverer did not dream up anything new but instead passively described what was already there. One might say, for instance, that though James Clerk Maxwell’s description of invisible electromagnetic waves was an unprecedented idea, Maxwell did not originate that idea itself, the idea being the phenomenon that had existed and would continue to exist absent of anyone discovering it.

Such an objection would not be valid; the natural phenomenon was not human-made but the first proper scientific description of it is human-made and therefore human-originated. However, there are many instances in history of someone being original not in being the first to discover a phenomenon of Nature but in conceiving of something human-made that is new and original. There are many such instances of originality in the early history of cartoon animation.

The earliest-known animation caught on motion-picture film was not hand-drawn animation but stop-motion animation. To create a stop-motion film, you first place a posable object in front of a camera and take one frame capture of it. Then you move the object slightly and, with that object being in the new pose, you take another frame capture of it. This process is repeated to create many frames. When the entire film reel is run, it should appear that the object is moving on its own. The earliest-known motion picture to feature stop-motion animation is The Humpty-Dumpty Circus made in the year 1898 by J. Stuart Blackton and stage-magician-turned-filmmaker Albert E. Smith.

Then in 1903 J. Stuart Blackton tried again, this time with hand-drawn animation, though the drawings were not done on either paper or celluloid. Instead Blackton used chalk on a chalkboard. He did the drawing in chalk and took a frame capture of it. Then he erased a subtle part of the drawing and made a subtle change, only to take another frame capture of it. Upon repetition of this process, Blackton created a motion picture that made it appear as though the drawing on the chalkboard was moving by itself. This was Humorous Phases of Funny Faces. Not all of the movie was animated though; there were live-action shots of Blackton’s hand moving.

In France in 1908 Émile Cohl released what is often considered the first true cartoon animation, his Fantasmagorie. It was unlike Humorous Phases of Funny Faces in that the entire film was done in hand-drawn animation, making it the first film that was fully hand-drawn animation. It was also the earliest-known hand-drawn animated film in which the drawings were done on paper. Something else original was that Phantasmagorie used animation to depict scenes that sequences that absolutely could not have occurred in real life, such as of a wine bottle transforming into a flower.

Then Winsor McCay, known for his newspaper comic Little Nemo, entered the animation business as well. An early project of his adapted Little Nemo for a hand-drawn animated motion picture Little Nemo Moving Comics in 1911. This, by the way, is the earliest-known hand-drawn animated motion picture to be adapted from a newspaper comic strip. Then in 1914 McCay came out with Gertie the Dinosaur.

Making this latter movie, McCay pioneered a number of important techniques. The figures in the animations of J. Stuart Blackton and Émile Cohl, including the backgrounds, would “jump” and shake from one frame to the next. To stop that, McCay would draw a stationary background and duplicate it for multiple frames. He also put crosshairs on the frames further as a guide to maintain consistency. Then he pioneered the “key-frame system.” Here, he would start out drawing the most important frames where the character’s (Gertie the Dinosaur’s) emotions were expressed and changed, and then he would go back later and draw the “in-between” frames — the transitions between the key ones. That practice of “key-framing” is one that is still regularly performed by animators to the day of this writing.

Further innovations came from John R. Bray. He found it cumbersome that in order to keep the background consistent for an entire scene, McCay would re-trace by hand his own drawing of that background. It was Bray who decided that for an entire scene there should be a single painted background. The animated characters in the foreground would be inked onto transparent celluloid sheets that would be overlayed on top of the background. The foreground characters’ postures would change slightly in each new frame. Bray patented this process. The process was then improved by another animator, Earl Hurd. What Hurd added to the process was that on the reverse side of each celluloid sheet featuring the foreground characters, foreground characters’ bodies would be painted colorfully. Hurd gained his own patent, which he eventually pooled with Bray’s. The placement of these cels — the foreground characters being posed a bit differently for each frame — over stationary painted backgrounds became standard practice in the industry for the latter half of the twentieth century.

Although McKay and Bray had developed methods to keep the background stationary, the outlines of the animated foreground characters remained unstable and jerky. But then another animation pioneer, Max Fleischer, devised a method to change that. Fleischer invented rotoscoping. The artist would place a transparent cel over a frame capture from a live-action film and then, onto the transparent cel, trace the outline of the live-action actor. Once every cel for the animated movie’s scene had been finished and put together to create the desired animated scene, the foreground figure in the animation would move in perfect concert with the live-action actor. This resulted in the smoothest-moving animation yet seen. And, pertinent to what Fleischer intended, the outlines of the foreground characters didn’t “jump” around so jerkily anymore; the outlines remained affixed to their respective foreground characters. Fleischer patented this rotoscoping. Walt Disney would use it as well in his own animated features.

Historians of animation — yes, there is indeed such an academic discipline — have even found what might be the earliest examples of a particular storytelling convention in cartoons. The convention is that when a character experiences an electric shock, that is conveyed visually by the character’s body flashing like a light, and in which, during every other flash, all of the character’s body is black except for the skeleton underneath being visible temporarily — as in one of Wilhelm Röntgen’s X-rays. When someone receives an electric shock in real life, the person’s skeleton does not become visible like that. This raises curiosity over how this visual storytelling convention began. Historians think they have an answer.

Prior to opening his animation studio, Max Fleischer worked as an illustrator for Popular Science magazine. At the time, two topics had been garnering much of the attention from the scientific world — 1) the then-emerging electric-power industry and 2) Röntgen’s then-recent discovery of X-rays. As these topics were relatively new to the public, it was common for members of the public to get them mixed up.

When working on a Popeye the Sailor Man cartoon, Fleischer wanted to convey visually that Popeye received a bad electric shock. As he thought his audience would assume X-rays are similar to electricity, Fleischer decided to convey that Popeye was being electro-shocked by having an outline of his skeleton flash as though he was being X-rayed. And that image made such an impression that, to this day, it is a convention in cartoons.




Conclusion
As we have seen, a discovery or invention or artwork can be identified properly as an original feat when it possesses specific-but-crucial details that are unprecedented. That is how we attain progress in culture where there are net gains in economic value.

Steve Jobs was wrong. Great artists don’t steal. Great artists create something new.







On Thu., Nov. 5, 2026, I added the examples of commentators denying the reality of originality. On Monday, November 9, 2026, I added the explanation of the how the decisiveness in the specific-but-decisive originality of Charles Darwin and the Wright brothers refers to their originality achieving practical results not achieved by contemporaries and predecessors within the general idea of their area of study, contemporaries and predecessors with whom Darwin and the Wright brothers are compared unfavorably by the originality-deniers.